- This topic has 117 replies, 30 voices, and was last updated 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
and using the same robots until they fail isn’t an option in my opinion because the idea is to stay up to date with the current market not just some random EAs that work (out of luck?).
What I was looking for was a clear strategy how I can be profitable using the top 10 robots app. Clear instructions. Like “only bots that meet criteria xyz” I tried almost everything and since almost one year im still trading on demo only because I don’t have a reliable reproductive strategy to make money in the long run using those bots.
Yes you might have luckily found some good ones, but since there aren’t updated they will fail at some point. That’s what I mean with reducible. The new ones you put on the demo account then might fail immediately. So it seems you also didn’t found any sustainable profitable strategy using this app. That’s so sad since we paid so much. Im very very sad because the Idea was logical to me. But those bots even with the new out of sample filter seem to be curve fitted.
Oh and btw: it is easy to show me profits and argue that those bots are profitable. Yes, some are but no one will give clear instructions how to reproduce it. They run 10 Demo accounts with different bots and if one is profitable they show you those results while the other 9 accounts imploded.
thank you for sharing your thoughts with us. Since we didn’t heard anything from you since then I wanted to ask how are things going? Your approach made much sense but since im trying to make any profits since months using this app your idea might be my last resort. I hope your approach made some good returns since then?
Im thrilled to hear from you
Greetings
Hi Bob,
Sorry to hear you are having problems being successful using the Top10 app robots. The problem I see with using the Top10 app robots is that they are created and tested using Blackbull historical data. The problem with historical data is that it is difference with with many difference forex brokers. So, you have two options. One option is to use the Blackbull forex broker, or two, test the robots with your broker. This is what I did. I downloaded all the Top10 robots and backtested them all with Oanda to find which ones produced a nice balance line. From this test I then picked the best performing ones to trade. Notice with the Top10 robots I am trading on Oanda I call it a test. This is because I want to test them for about four to six months before trading them on a live account. This test account is still doing very well with a balance of $110,500 or 10% over the last 90 days.
Hi Zoran,
When you move a robot from a demo account to a live account there are two things you should do. One is to make sure you are using the same broker for both the demo and live accounts. Secondly, keep the robot on the demo account and also on the live account. This will let you know if the demo account and the live account are using the same historical data. By doing this when you see the live account in a drawdown you can check the demo account to see if it is also going through the same drawdown. What you did by moving from a demo account to a live account and found that with the live account the robot starting losing you don’t know if the live account is the problem or if it is just going through a drawdown. If you find the demo account and the live account produce different results you can always use a trade copier. I use the free trade copier from FXblue to do this very thing. I test all my robots with just one broker and when I want to trade them with a different broker, such as a prop firm, I use a trade copier.
Guys, also note I am no longer using the forum or adding content. I do however, get an email when you guys post something so I can still respond to questions but I will not be adding content once a week.
Alan-
Hi Bob!
Try NDX 100, it is ONLY instrument that works right now. Start looking in 1Y, smoothe line, drowdown less than 3%, must be in 1M and 1W chart. 5-6 of them put in demo, after 5 trades you will decide what to do with them. Best of them install in live account with the SAME broker. Before deploying them, TEST in MT5 for 1Y, 1M and 1W with real (yours) delays and other options. They are active mostly during first NY Kill Zone. Good luck!
ZoranHey Alan,
Does Blackbull work in the US? whenever i try to create account it says not available in your region.
Secondly, do you use VPS or you leave your PC on 24/7? My VPS can only handle 4-6 MT4/MT5 app. This restrict me from creating multiple demo account for different scenarios.Hi devgabriel300,
The broker Blackbull does not allow for US traders.
The problem I have found with VPS’s is they only allow for about 4 or 5 Metatrader terminals.I have over 20 Mt4 and MT5 terminals running continuously so to have 4 or 5 VPS’s is extremely costly. I found it more economical to run my Metatrader terminals on my own pc. So what I did was to purchase a separate pc. I actually bought a used pc off the internet. I have it connected to a battery backup. I also use T-Mobile Home internet connected to my pc connected to the battery backup. This device gets its internet from the cell tower instead of a hard wired internet connection. The problem with hard wired internet connections is they go down a few times a year. Cell towers hardly ever go down! Even if you just use your normal internet connection and it goes down a couple times a year and stays down for 24 hours each time that is still an uptime of 99.24%.
Hope this helps!
Alan,
Yes it does, It makes sense now, cos getting additional VPS was an expensive option. I will use your technique. Thanks for sharing.
Hello Marin,
I recently bought a pack of 10 top EAs. Could you advise me on how long it is optimal to evaluate the EA? Right now I am testing the top 5 EAs from each pair according to monthly statistics. Thank you for your advice and good luck!
Lukáš
Consistent performance from Top 10 Gold EAs for over 1 year.
Purchased Petko Top 10 Gold EAs and been running all 10 (Yearly EA) in a Demo and selecting the top 5 for live account for over a year.
Even if you are lazy like me and just leave all 10 in the live account you still made significant profits. Limiting to top 5 and checking weekly on all EAs and cherry picking the best gives you even better results. Also, every week I see if there are any new Top 10 yearly EAs and add to demo and once I get a good few months of profits, I also add them.https://www.fxblue.com/users/petkotop10goldea_dec
Password: 1045867It’s a 1K AUD account on Pepperstone, been going since Jan 25. My other older Demo accounts were cancelled by Pepperstone in their last cleanup. Just returned +326.6% profit (Closed profit: +3,145.98) as of 20/06/2025.
Basically, give it time, there are some weeks of downtown (traffics in April was bad !), but month on month it’s making good money on small balance of 1K AUD.Obviously, this forum is dead as a mouse… Anyone here with a strategy that works with the Top-10-EAs?? I am testing several strategies for months, but to be honest I can’t find a tactic that really works, it’s up and down, and again up and down… Even more frustrating is the fact that the Petko and his team imho don’t give a s**t about bringing the Top-10-EAs to the next level… What about other symbols like AUDCAD? What about the long promised “portfolio solution”? I am following their channel, what I can see recently is that they are mostly focussing on presenting expensive third party EAs (even some with quite questionable websites), of course all with an affiliate link… It’s frustrating that customers who paid quite a substantial amount for the Top-10-EA (like myself) don’t get any attention after a purchase…
I could not be more agree with Alesamo. Just look at the results of “100k Project”.Where are Top 10 EAs and what scores they achieve?
My goal was to cover expenses of buying Top 10 EAs and move on. I success that, but with hard work, making my own strategy based on my mistakes and YouTube clips. Paying 149 euro/month for VIP Club is tooooo much expensive. I paid that amount and less for lifetime access in other communities.
First, forget about demo account for testing. Many times I saw that some EA is a Rock Star on demo account, but when I put it on live, it is a Looser. Solution is to open small real account for testing.
Conditions to choose EA from Top 10 App is that you are chasing profit out of sample and EA must be on Y, M and W table. I noticed that EAs from Top 10 EAs have a very tiny lifetime, so you must catch the peak: after 5 trades, you make decision if it goes to main live account.
Condition to remove EA is to calculate Risk to Reward Ratio (RRR) a that higher round number is amount of consecutive losses which I am ready to loose.
Hope that help a little bit.
Zoran
Hello Alesamo,
Thank you for your honest feedback and for being a part of our community. I understand your frustration with the current performance of the Top-10 EAs and the feeling that progress might be slow.
Please know that we are committed to continually improving the EAs and developing new solutions, including the long-awaited portfolio approach. These developments take time, as we prioritize stability, reliability, and compliance with prop firm rules.
Regarding other symbols like AUDCAD, we are actively testing and optimizing strategies across various pairs. That’s also why we offer carefully tested third-party robots—to provide our clients with a wider variety of trading options while we continue developing our own solutions.
About the third-party EAs: we are doing our best to offer a variety of robots to our clients, but only after successful testing and thorough evaluation. Our aim is to provide additional tools that can complement our core products and help traders find what works best for their style.
Your investment and trust are important to us, and I encourage you to reach out with any specific issues or suggestions so we can assist you more directly. We appreciate your patience and continued support as we work to bring the best possible tools to our traders.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.