Hi David,
The best thing would be to try them both simultaneously so you will see which one works best.
Just put 10 same EAs on 2 different Demo account, and apply the other EA in one of the accounts.
I can’t say which is better because I haven’t tested your option, and it’s hard to predict the outcome as it’s not possible to perform a backtest on the 10 EAs and the AP EA.
Let us know the results if you do the test.
Cheers.