Hi Alan,

thanks for the detailed informations. I have a darwinex zero account in the training phase where I was trading the Forex Gold Investor. After the big DD on the 12th of April when it lost 12% of the account I stopped it. I have also another brand new 25k challenge with FX2 Funding, that I have to start trading soon. I would then rather get the Prop Firm Robots to pass this challenge, but what would happen if I use it on the Darwinex account? And also if I pass the FX Funding challenge – is there a posibility to make the trades look unique – maybe change magic number, comment or something? After all the benfeit of passing a challenge is to trade the account. I see in the results that you have funded account trading with EAs, the Forex Gold Investor is not the best one at the moment though, which one would you use? Thanks!

Boyan

Hi Alan,

so these are the Prop Firm robots, correct?

So these are 14 Prop Firm Robots for 14 different assets, which I would be able to export from the Prop Firm Robots App. This is my first option.

And these are 100 EAs wich I would be able to export from the Top 10 EAs app, right? This would be my option 2. 

Since the Top 10 EAs have not been trading for a month yet, the results for the last 30 days cannot be really compared to the Prop Firm Robots. And since the Top 10 EAs are more recently developed, which one do you suggest is better for passing a challenge and trading on a funded account? Just your opinion, not a financial advice of course, thanks!

Boyan

Hi Alan,

I thought it was clear, but now I am even more confused. I thought the strategies are anchored in the single EAs. Now you tell me, that the apps have different strategies? The two offers about the 100 EAs, that you told me are the same, are listed once under Prop Firm Robots(the left one) and once under Top 10 Forex Robots(on the right with the discount). However if I get the discounted EAs I would be able to extract them only from the Top 10 EAs app, and the results from the screenshot are fromm the Prop Firms App. So could you please explain if I get the discounted EAs will they be suitable for passing a challenge? Thanks!

Boyan

Hi Alan,

thank you, this is what I thought – the offers look preety much the same. The question for me is if those are the EAs that achieved the results in the table under challenges results, becuase it says Prop Firm Robots there?

As to the EAs – what would be the use of the Top 10 EAs app since Petko ist trading all of the strategies in a portfolio and then he just picks only the profitable for the live account? Thank you und sorry if I aks too many questions, just trying to figure out what is most suitable for my prop challenges.

Boyan

Hi Alan,

thank you for the clarification. What about the other question – is the Top 10 EAs app ranking the top 10 out of many more? And do you know what the difference between these two offers is?

Thans!

Boyan

Hi,

refering to the user guide of the Top 10 EAs U have a couple of questions. Is the app actually ranking Top 10 EAs out of many more per pair? Could you please explain one more time how you activate only certain EAs from the portfolio to trade on the live account? Petko said that in the demo account all the EAs in the portfilio are enabled and trading while testing. Then he removes the slashes of two of them in the code and they become active, but what about the other ones? Thanks!

Boyan

 

Hello,

I am trying to figure out what are the differences between the Prop Firm robots an the Top 10 EAs and which ones are more suitable for passing a challenge. So far I figured out, that the Prop Firm robots contain 14 EAs, each trading different instruments, while the Top 10 EAs contain up to 100 EAs – 10 instruments with 10 strategies each – is that correct? I took a look at the results and I see that the Prop firms robots performed a lot better in the challenges than the Top 10 EAs in the live accounts – but as far as I see in the track record the Top 10 EAs have been running only for a week or so, so they cannot rally be compared. So I am not sure which one is my better choice, please get back with me soon, so I can possibly take advantage of the 50% discount if I decide to get the Top 10 EAs. Thanks!

Boyan

Hi,

I checked the reults of the Forex Diamond EA on the live account and on the challenge and on the live account is the performance siginificantly better. What might be the reason for this, are theing being run with different set files? Thanks!

Boyan

Hi Alan,

thanks a lot. I might have mixed up the topics. Can just please clarify – are the Prop Firm Robots(former FTMO robot) a different animal from the Top 10 EAs, I am getting quite confused. Tnaks again!

best regards

Boyan

Hello,

after the fail of the Forex Gold Investor on last Friday, I stopped using it for a while and I am looking for a new EA , because I want to continue trading my darwinex zero account and also my brand new FX2 Funding challenge which I also have to start trading within 30 days. According to the current trading results you post the two candidates would be the Forex Diamond EA and the Top 10 App Robots and I have some questions about those.

– Firstly why does the Forex Diamond EA performs differently in the last 30 days on the live account results and on the challenges results(find the screenshots in the attachments)?

– secondly you have in the results on the live account the Top 10 App(XAUUSD) and on the challenges the Prop Firm Robots which is performing a lot better during the last 30 days. What is the difference between these two?

– and last but not least – when I click on Top 10 App(XAUUSD) in the Live acoount results table and on the Prop Firm Robots  in the challenges resukts table I get different offers to purchase – see the screenshot comparison in the attachment. I thought there is a 50% discound this week on all plans of the Top 10 robots can you please explain? And I also do not understand the difference of the offers on the left and on the right side – the first two columns on the left are included only10 Gold Robots – what about the first two columns on the right side – what is here included? And also the third column – on the left it is 100 EAs and on the right side only 10 although double the price?

Please get back with me soon as I want to make up my mind anf take advantage of the discount. Thanks a lot!

best regards
Boyan

Hi Alan,

I started a new topic called ‘Top 10 EAs general questions and 50% discount’ where I also attached some screenshots but it says now ‘This topic is pending moderation.’ and I cannot see it. Is it posted or something went wrong and I have to do it again? Thank you!

best regards

Boyan

Hi Andy,

didn’t you have max. DD set in the Gold Investor? I also had a bad experience on Friday, the market moved a lot downwards, the EA kept buying and hitting SL until I stopped it manually, it lost more than 12% on may account and I had max. DD set to 4, but it did not worked. It was doing pretty good until last Thursday, it made +6% wuthin 5 trading days, but it took less than 2 hours to go into big DD. I am very disappointed and I am thinking about returning it within the 60 day period that ends up today. I am waiting on a responce from the support though, what are your thoughts on this?

Hi Alan,

I am not in the US and mt4 is available. As far as I know the EAs can be run only on the metaquotes platforms, so there must be a solution for the prop firms. Please let me know if you find that kind of copier, thanks!

Boyan

Hi Alan,

FTMO is currently still supporting mt4 so I don’t need the copier there. My problem is that I bought a FX2 challenge just before they switched to DXtrade, so the copier is my only option I guess. And I have not found one yet, still searching.

 

Boyan

Thanks a lot!